Ghoul Vibrations: press release.

[Parascience]

Oops.

I don't define Infrasound as all sund below 20Hz because I didn't write the definitions. Not an Oops.

Oops again.

I used some important words that you seem to have missed - In Excess of. Not therefore a 2nd Oops.


Just wanted to make those minor points for the sake of clarity - the rest we can debate another day - As I said to Jason, we need to rest this for a while. Thank-you for your contribution to an interesting debate so far, I look forward to further discussions in the future

Steve

[Dr B]

We look forward to the methods and results steve Seems a shame not to bring them here for open discussion.

My hunch is, if you used true-infrasound (IAV), then there will be no effect of it relative to appropriate baselines (shame about the double-blind). If you used higher-amplitude sound - then you may get effects - due to sound.

In addition, if you did not screen your participants (for perceptual thresholds via SDT or something similar) - the data could be more problematic for interpretation. In some cases the energy may have been audible - though not necessarily as clear sound....and may have led to more misattributions. This would still be using basic early sound-perception mechanisms though and so, would be no evidence at all for a special mechanism for true-infrasound (IAV). Just a thought......

[Parascience]

We look forward to the methods and results steve Seems a shame not to bring them here for open discussion.

All in good time! I wouldn't be happy discussing areas of the experiment that are the work of others within the experiment team and I'm sure that members of this forum would also prefer to debate with the fullest information at their disposal too.

[Dr B]

Of course

Why not invite them over here to provide the information when they are ready

[Dr B]

Is there any update on this that anyone knows about - either specific to the project discussed here or any other projects?

[Dr B]

bump....

someone brought it to my attention recently that these people are now talking about the importance of perceptual thresholds (as discussed at length above by myself and Cuddles / and Median) - though we are not cited, ackowledged or thanked.........not for the first time these people show somewhat lax memories and self-perception.